Charlotte salad potatoes

Which Potato Varieties Are The Best For Salads?

The humble potato: a staple in cuisines around the world and a versatile foundation in our diets. With over 4,000 edible varieties, potatoes are not a one-size-fits-all ingredient, especially when it comes to making the perfect salad. The choice of potato can make a significant difference in taste, texture, and overall satisfaction.

In this article, we will delve into the best potato varieties for salads, focusing on selections from the US and UK.

Criteria for the Ideal Salad Potato

A potato ideal for salad needs to possess a few key characteristics. Firstly, it should hold its shape well when cooked and cooled, ensuring a good bite and texture. Additionally, the flavour should be subtly earthy and sweet, pairing well with a variety of dressings and additional ingredients. Lastly, the potato’s skin should contribute positively to the salad’s texture rather than detract from it.

Overview of Potato Varieties in the US and UK

The US and UK are both known for a wide range of potato varieties, each with unique characteristics. Varieties range from starchy Russets, beloved for their fluffy texture when baked or mashed, to waxy new potatoes that hold their shape beautifully in a dish. Recognizing these characteristics is crucial to creating a mouth-watering potato salad.

Top US Potato Varieties for Salads

In the US, three potato varieties often steal the show in salad preparation: Norland Reds, Yukon Gold, and Fingerlings.

Norland Reds, often smaller and round, hold their shape excellently when boiled due to their low starch content. Their subtly sweet and creamy flesh complements many different types of salad dressings.

Yukon Gold potatoes, a favourite in many American kitchens, offer a buttery flavour and a slightly waxy texture. They maintain their structure well in salads, and their golden flesh adds a vibrant touch to the dish.

Fingerlings are elongated, small potatoes, with a firm texture that withstands boiling or roasting. Their earthy and nutty flavour profiles add a depth to salads that can be a delightful surprise.

Top UK Potato Varieties for Salads

In the UK, the salad potato crown often goes to Charlotte, Maris Peer, and Jazzy potatoes.

Charlotte potatoes are a popular salad variety, boasting a firm texture and a delicious, subtly sweet flavour. Their elongated shape and yellow flesh add a touch of elegance to any salad.

Maris Peer potatoes, renowned for their smooth skin and creamy flesh, maintain their shape beautifully in salads. They offer a light, slightly nutty flavour, perfect for a traditional English potato salad.

Jazzy potatoes are a small, waxy variety with a smooth yellow skin and cream-coloured flesh. Their excellent firmness and slightly buttery flavour make them an excellent choice for salads.

The Case for Not Peeling Salad Potatoes

While peeling potatoes can sometimes be a preferred method in cooking, when it comes to salad, it’s often better to leave the skin on. Here’s why:

Nutrition: A significant amount of a potato’s nutritional value is in its skin. This includes fiber, vitamin B, vitamin C, iron, calcium, and potassium. Peeling potatoes removes these valuable nutrients.

Flavor and Texture: Potato skins add a pleasant earthy flavour and a slightly chewy texture, which contrasts nicely with the soft potato flesh, enhancing the overall salad experience.

Visual Appeal: The skin of a potato, particularly in red and purple varieties, provides a pop of colour to your potato salad, making the dish more visually appealing.

Remember, if you choose to leave the skins on, ensure your potatoes are thoroughly cleaned to remove any dirt.

Case Studies: Best Potato Salads Recipes using the Selected Varieties

Famous recipes often call for these specific potato varieties. For example, a classic American potato salad might feature Yukon Golds, tossed with mayonnaise, mustard, and a sprinkle of chopped dill pickles.

On the other hand, a traditional English potato salad may showcase Maris Peers, dressed simply with mayonnaise and a sprinkle of fresh chives.

Tips and Tricks for Making the Perfect Potato Salad

To make an outstanding potato salad, start by selecting the right potato. Then, ensure you cook them correctly. Potatoes should be started in cold, salted water and brought to a simmer to ensure even cooking.

After cooking, let the potatoes cool completely before adding your dressing to prevent it from being absorbed too much, which can lead to a soggy salad.

Don’t shy away from experimenting with additional ingredients such as fresh herbs, crispy bacon, or even a dash of hot sauce for an extra kick. The possibilities are limitless when you begin with the perfect potato foundation.


Potatoes are more than just a side dish; they are a culinary playground. Selecting the right potato variety can transform your salads from ordinary to extraordinary. So the next time you are preparing a potato salad, consider reaching for a Norland Red, a Charlotte, or perhaps even a Jazzy potato. Enjoy the exploration and culinary creativity.

Further reading: